Hickory House Restaurant Menu Prices

Relaxed eatery with a warm atmosphere serving barbecue fare, steaks, burgers & seafood.

The Hickory House is the best steakhouse in Reynoldsburg serving up quality steak since 1979. The Hickory House is known for the best Porterhouse Steak in the business. Our ribs are the finest two-pound baby backs money can buy. Our seven-spice rib rub and original Bar-B-Que sauce are made from scratch. All our steaks are hand cut, never frozen, from the best available aged, choice cut beef. A deliberate decision to serve quality steak and ribs at The Hickory House has caused customers to come back again and again.

  4.4 – 1 reviews  $$ • Steak house

Photo Gallery

Menu

Dinner Menu
Appetizers
Bar-B-Que Ribs
Our Award Winning pork loin baby back ribs basted in our homemade sauce
$8.95
Hickory House Wings
Ten breaded wings served with our homemade Bar-B-Que sauce or Buffalo sauce
$9.95
Sweet Corn Nuggets
Sweet creamed style corn dipped in a light crispy batter and served with homemade ranch
$8.95
Onion Straws
Flash fried and served with our homemade Bar-B-Que sauce
$5.50
Shrimp Cocktail
Five jumbo chilled shrimp served with cocktail sauce and a lemon wedge
$13.95
Grilled Shrimp
Four succulent shrimp broiled or Bar-B-Qued with Creole dipping sauce
$11.95
Deep Fried Jumbo Shrimp
Four jumbo shrimp fried golden brown, served with cocktail sauce and a lemon wedge
$8.50
Hickory Chips
Topped with cheddar and bacon bits, served with our famous Bar-B-Que sauce
$7.95
Soups
French Onion Soup au Gratin
Made from scratch daily
$5.95
Soup of the Day
Made from scratch daily
$5.95
Salads
Dinner Salad $4.50
Grilled Chicken & Cranberry Salad
Grilled chicken served over mixed field greens with cranberry craisins, sliced almonds, red onion and Blue Cheese; tossed with raspberry vinaigrette
$14.50
Southwest Chicken Salad
Romaine lettuce topped with homemade black bean corn salsa (roasted corn, black beans, jalapenos, cilantro and lime juice), fresh diced tomatoes, cheddar cheese and tortilla strips; topped with your choice of grilled or fried chicken; served with homemade Ranch dressing
$14.95
Caesar Salad $5.95
Cobb Salad
Fresh greens, turkey, tomato, bacon, hard boiled egg and crumbled Blue Cheese
$13.95
Steakhouse Salad
Grilled steak, mixed field greens, diced tomato, onion, sliced almonds and crumbled Blue Cheese
$15.95
Signature Salad
Garden fresh greens tossed with House dressing, crumbled Blue Cheese and real bacon
$6.50
Sandwiches
Tony Burger
Flame broiled half pound burger topped with BBQ Sauce, Cheddar Cheese, cole slaw and a crisp onion ring
$10.95
Mushroom Burger
A half pound burger with mozzarella and mushrooms
$10.95
Chicken Breast Sandwich
Served broiled, Bar-B-Qued or buffalo style, on a Kaiser roll with lettuce and tomato
$9.95
Submarine Sandwich
Ham, salami, mozzarella, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, banana peppers and our special sauce
$10.95
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Hand pulled, tossed with our homemade Bar-B-Que sauce and served on a Kaiser Roll
$10.95
Seafood
North Atlantic Salmon
Eight ounces served broiled with herb butter or Bar-B-Que glaze
$20.50
Butterflied Jumbo Shrimp
Six jumbo shrimp fried golden crisp and served with a lemon wedge and cocktail sauce
$17.95
Grilled Shrimp Dinner
Six succulent shrimp lightly seasoned and flame broiled. Served with Creole tarter sauce
$22.95
Haddock
Ten ounces served broiled, breaded or battered
$18.50
Steak, Chops & Chicken
Filet Mignon
Completely trimmed center cut
$28.95
Bone-in Ribeye
Fourteen – sixteen ounce, tender, full of flavor
$33.95
New York Strip
Fourteen ounce boneless center cut
$29.50
Signature Cut Pork Chops
Two center cut, seven ounce chops broiled or Bar-B-Qued to perfection
$19.95
Pasta Rossi
Sautéed chicken, mushrooms and penne pasta tossed in a light roasted red pepper cream sauce, then baked with a toasted Parmesan crust. Includes dinner salad only
$16.95
Chicken Alfredo
Fettuccine noodles with fresh, made-to-order Alfredo sauce and seasoned chicken, topped with shredded Parmesan cheese, parsley and paprika. Includes dinner salad only
$16.95
Top Sirloin
Eight ounce center cut
$19.45
Ribeye
Fourteen ounce, tender, full of flavor
$29.50
Ground Sirloin
Choice ground sirloin topped with sautéed onions
$16.95
Boneless Chicken Breasts
Two six ounce breasts served broiled or Bar-B-Qued
$16.95
Half Chicken
A half chicken perfectly seasoned with our signature spices, served broiled or Bar-B-Qued
$18.95
Bar-B-Qued Meatloaf
Served over garlic mashed potatoes and topped with onion straws; served with the fresh vegetable of the day and dinner salad
$16.95
House Specialty
Porterhouse Steak
Two best quality cuts on one bone
$25.95
House Specialty Addition
Sautéed Mushrooms $3.75
Sautéed Onions $3.00
Sautéed Mushrooms & Onions $3.50
Blue Cheese $2.00
Award Winning BBQ
Slab Dinner
A full slab of our famous baby back ribs
$21.95
Rib Dinner
A half slab of our famous baby back ribs
$18.95
Hickory House BBQ Platter
The best of everything BBQ—Our award winning ribs, mini pulled pork sandwich and one Bar-B-Qued chicken breast. Served with side and salad
$19.95
The Best Rack in Town
Carry Out Ala Carte Slab Only
$16.95
Our Combos
Top Sirloin
Bar-B-Qued Ribs
Butterflied or Grilled Shrimp
Broiled or Bar-B-Qued Boneless Chicken Breast
Signature Combos
Filet & Shrimp
Filet mignon paired with a skewer of our succulent grilled shrimp
$33.95
Filet & Ribs
Filet mignon paired with our award winning ribs
$32.95
Sides
Hand Cut Home Fries $2.95
Idaho Baked Potato $2.95
Garlic Mashed Potatoes $2.95
Fresh Seasonal Vegetables $2.95
Seasoned Rice Pilaf $2.95
Baked Sweet Potato
Served with honey cinnamon butter
$2.95
Hand Cut Fries $2.95
Mac & Cheese $2.95
Onion Rings $3.50
Onion Straws $2.95
Cole Slaw $2.95
Applesauce $2.95
Cottage Cheese $2.95
Desserts
Seasonal Cakes & Pies Made in House $5.95
Crème Brulee
Homemade custard topped with caramelized sugar and a dollop of whipped cream
$5.95
Cookie Skillet
Fresh baked chocolate chip cookie topped with vanilla ice cream, chocolate & caramel drizzle, whipped cream and a cherry; Serves two. Please allow extra time as cookies are baked fresh upon ordering
$7.95
Ice Cream Sundae
Vanilla ice cream covered in chocolate & caramel drizzle, whipped cream and a cherry
$4.95
Kid’s Menu
Hamburger $5.95
Cheeseburger $6.95
Mini Corn Dogs (5) $5.95
Chicken Tenders (3) $6.95
Butterfly Shrimp (3) $7.95
Grilled Shrimp (3) $8.95
Bar-B-Que Ribs (4 Bones) $9.95
Petite Top Sirloin (5oz.) $9.95
Homemade Dressings and Sauces by the Jar
Bar-B-Que Sauce $5.95
House Sweet & Sour Dressing $4.95
Homemade Blue Cheese Dressing $5.95
Seven-Spice Rib Seasoning $4.95
Homemade Ranch Dressing $4.95
Lunch Menu
Appetizers
Bar-B-Que Ribs
Our Award Winning pork loin baby back ribs basted in our homemade sauce
$8.95
Hickory House Wings
Ten breaded wings served with our homemade Bar-B-Que sauce or Buffalo sauce
$9.95
Onion Straws
Flash fried and served with our homemade Bar-B-Que sauce
$6.95
Sweet Corn Nuggets
Sweet creamed style corn dipped in a light crispy batter and served with homemade ranch
$8.95
Deep Fried Jumbo Shrimp
Four jumbo shrimp fried golden brown, served with cocktail sauce and a lemon wedge
$8.50
Grilled Shrimp
Four succulent shrimp broiled or Bar-B-Qued with Creole dipping sauce
$11.95
Hickory Chips
Topped with melted cheddar and bacon bits, served with our famous Bar-B-Que sauce
$7.95
Soups
French Onion Soup Au Gratin
Made from scratch daily
$5.95
Soup of the Day
Made from scratch daily
$5.95
Salads
Dinner Salad $4.50
Steakhouse Salad
Grilled steak, mixed field greens, diced tomato, onion, sliced almonds and crumbled Blue Cheese
$15.95
Signature Salad
Garden fresh greens tossed with House dressing, crumbled Blue Cheese and real bacon
$6.50
Caesar Salad $5.95
Cobb Salad
Fresh greens, turkey, tomato, bacon, hard boiled egg and crumbled Blue Cheese
$13.95
Grilled Chicken & Cranberry Salad
Grilled chicken served over mixed field greens with cranberry craisins, sliced almonds, red onion and Blue Cheese; tossed with raspberry vinaigrette
$14.50
Soup and Salad Combos
French Onion Soup Au Gratin or Soup of the Day, and Dinner Salad. (Additional charge for Blue Cheese dressing and Signature Salad)
$9.95
Melts
Meatloaf Melt
Homemade Bar-B-Qued Glazed Meatloaf topped with Bar-B-Que sauce, Provolone Cheese, lettuce, onion and tomato; served on Sourdough bread
$10.95
Patty Melt
Flame broiled half pound burger smothered with Swiss cheese and sautéed onions; served on grilled rye bread
$10.95
Lunch Baskets
Fish & Chips
Fresh Haddock fried golden crisp, served with hand cut fries and a garnish of cole slaw
$11.50
Chicken Tenders
Delicious chicken tenders fried golden brown, served with hand cut fries and a garnish of cole slaw
$9.95
House Specialties
Lunch Strip
Eight ounce boneless center cut broiled to perfection, served with onion rings and hand cut fries
$13.95
Butterflied Jumbo Shrimp
our jumbo shrimp fried golden crisp and served with a lemon wedge and cocktail sauce. Served with choice of one side
$10.95
The Porterhouse Steak
The steak that made us famous! Two of the best quality cuts on one bone. Served with side and salad
$25.95
Ground Sirloin
Eight ounce choice ground sirloin topped with sautéed onions and served with one side
$11.95
House Specialties Additions
Sautéed Mushrooms $3.75
Sautéed Onions $3.00
Sautéed Mushrooms & Onions $3.50
Blue Cheese $2.00
Award Winning Ribs
Lunch Portion
A lunch portion of our famous ribs served with hand cut fries and cole slaw
$10.95
Slab Dinner
A full slab of our famous baby back ribs served with a side and salad
$21.95
The Best Rack in Town
Carry Out Ala Carte Slab Only
$16.95
Sandwiches
Tony Burger
Flame broiled half pound burger topped with BBQ Sauce, Cheddar Cheese, cole slaw and a crisp onion ring
$10.95
Mushroom Burger
A half pound burger with mozzarella and mushrooms
$10.95
Chicken Breast Sandwich
Served broiled, Bar-B-Qued or buffalo style, on a Kaiser roll with lettuce and tomato
$9.95
Reuben
Your choice of corned beef or turkey
$10.95
Submarine Sandwich
Ham, salami, mozzarella, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, banana peppers and our special sauce
$7.95
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Hand pulled, tossed with our homemade Bar-B-Que sauce and served on a Kaiser Roll
$10.95
Sides
Hand Cut Home Fries $2.95
Idaho Baked Potato $2.95
Fresh Seasonal Vegetables $2.95
Seasoned Rice Pilaf $2.95
Cottage Cheese $2.95
Hand Cut Fries $2.95
Mac & Cheese $2.95
Onion Rings $3.50
Onion Straws $2.95
Cole Slaw $2.95
Applesauce $2.95
Mashed Sweet Potatoes $2.95
Desserts
Cookie Skillet $7.95
Ice Cream Sundae
No Sugar Added Vanilla Ice Cream $3.95
Seasonal Cakes & Pies Made in House $5.95
Kid’s Menu
Hamburger $5.95
Cheeseburger $6.95
Mini Corn Dogs (5) $5.95
Chicken Tenders (3) $6.95
Butterfly Shrimp (3) $7.95
Grilled Shrimp (3) $8.95
Bar-B-Que Ribs (4 Bones) $9.95
Petite Top Sirloin (5 oz.) $9.95
Homemade Dressings and Sauces by the Jar
Bar-B-Que Sauce $5.95
House Sweet & Sour Dressing $4.95
Homemade Blue Cheese Dressing $5.95
Seven-Spice Rib Seasoning $4.95
Homemade Ranch Dressing $4.95
Catering Menu
Appetizers & Trays
Fresh Chicken Wings
Fresh wings made to order. Tossed with Buffalo or Bar-B-Que
$44.95
Veggie Tray
Serves 10. Vegetables are fresh and selected seasonally, ask for details. Also available on market value
$41.95
Meat Tray
Serves 10. Equal amounts of Ham, Roast Beef & Turkey. Additional cost may apply for substitutions. Also available on market value
$49.95
Shrimp Cocktail or Grilled Shrimp
Jumbo chilled shrimp served with cocktail sauce; or grilled shrimp served with Creole sauce. Also available on market value
$49.95
Cheese Tray
Serves 10. Colby, Pepper Jack, American, Cheddar, Swiss & Mozzarella. Also available on market value
$46.95
Bar-B-Que & More
Our Famous Baby Back Ribs
Sold by the slab, our Award Winning Ribs are seasoned in our seven-spice rib rub, slow cooked and basted in our Homemade Sauce-Fall-off-the-bone delicious!
$16.95
Pulled Chicken
Marinated and tossed in our homemade Bar-B-Que Sauce
$11.95
Pulled Pork
Seasoned and slow cooked, tossed with our homemade Bar-B-Que Sauce
$12.95
Half Chicken
Seasoned and served broiled or Bar-B-Qued
$12.95
Made From Scratch Sides
Baked Beans
Baked with real Bacon and our Bar-B-Que Sauce
$5.95
Mac n’ Cheese
Rich and creamy, always a favorite!
$6.95
Pasta Salad
Chef’s special-penne pasta with salami, cubed mozzarella, red bell pepper, broccoli and green olives, tossed in our special Italian dressing
$6.95
Fresh Green Beans
Lightly seasoned and sauteed to perfection!
$6.95
Coleslaw
Made from scratch – Fresh, Creamy and Delicious!
$5.95
Garden Salads
Fresh greens, tomatoes, onions and carrots; includes choice of one dressing. Blue cheese or multiple dressings are an additional cost
$15.95
Desserts and Extras
Desserts and Extras
Please call for our seasonal cakes and pies made in house
Happy Hour & Drink Menu
Drinks
Local Draft Beer $5.00
Well Drinks $4.50
House Wine $5.00
House Martinis $5.50
Smirnoff Beefeater $6.50
Food
Sampler Platter
BBQ Ribs, Wings, Onion Straws, Potato Skins & Corn Nuggets. No substitutions
$13.95
Boneless Wings
Served with your choice of homemade Bar-B-Que or Buffalo sauce
$8.95
Corn Beef Chips
Our homemade seasoned chips topped with melted cheddar corn beef and sauerkraut, served with a side of Thousand Island dressing
$9.95
Potstickers
Serve with ponzu or sweet and sour sauce
$6.95
Calamari
Served with sweet chili sauce
$9.95
Fried Banana Peppers
Sliced banana peppers lightly battered and flash fried, served with sweet & sour sauce
$6.95
Vodka
Absolute
Buckeye (Local)
Grey Goose
Kettle One
Smirnoff and Flavors
Stoli
Titos
Rum
Bacardi
Bacardi Mango
Captain Morgan’s
Erie Island (Local)
Malibu
Meyers
Gin
Beefeater
Benham’s
Bombay Sapphire
Hendricks
Tanqueray
Watershed (Local)
Tequila
1800
1800 Gold
1800 Silver
Cabo Wabo
Patron
Quervo
Sauza
Bourbon / Whiskey
Absolute
Basil Hayden
Buffalo Trace
Bulleit
Bulleit Rye
Bushmills (Irish)
C.C.
Crown
Crown Apple
Crown Vanilla
Gentleman Jack
Jack Daniels
Jameson (Irish)
Jim Beam
Knob Creek
Maker’s Mark
Red Stag
Seagram’s 7 / VO
Windsor
Woodford
Watershed (Local)
Blended Scotch
Cutty Sark
Dewar’s
Johnny Walker Black
Johnny Walker Red
Single Malt
Glenfiddich
Glenlivet
Laphroaig
McCallen
Cognac
Christian Brothers
Courvoisier
Hennessey VS
Remy Martin
White Wines
Chardonnay, Canyon Road – California
Chardonnay, Simi – California
Chardonnay, Hogue – Washington
Pinot Grigio, Canyon Road – California
Sauvignon Blanc, Canyon Road – California
Riesling, Chateau Ste. Michelle – Washington
Riesling, Hogue – Washington
Moscato, Canyon Road – California
White Zinfandel, Canyon Road – California
Apothic White Blend – California
White Wines – Available In Bottle Only
Chardonnay, William Hill – California
Red Wines
Cabernet Sauvignon, Canyon Road – California
Cabernet Sauvignon, Hogue – Washington
Cabernet Sauvignon, Raven’s Glenn – Ohio
Merlot, Canyon Road – California
Merlot, Hogue – Washington
Merlot, Raven’s Glenn – Ohio
Pinot Noir, Canyon Road – California
Malbec, Alamos – Argentina
Apothic Red Blend – California
R2 Red Blend, Raven’s Glenn – Ohio
Red Wines – Available by Bottle Only
Cabernet Sauvignon, Sterling – California
Cabernet Sauvignon, William Hill – California
Merlot, Sterling Vineyards – California
Pinot Noir, Louis Latour – France
Specialties
Sangria, House or Peach
Sparkling Wine
Cooks Split Sparkling Champagne
Retail Wine Night
Retail Wine Night
Our wine list changes on a regular basis (limited supplies)
Draft Beer
Draft Beer
Proudly serving rotating local drafts, including The Hickory House Ale. Ask your server or bartender about our Hickory House souvenir growler with your favorite beer
Domestic Bottled Beer
Blue Moon
Budweiser
Bud Light
Coors Light
Miller Light
Michelob Ultra
Sam Adams
Killians
O’Douls (N/A)
Imports & Local Beer
CBC (Local)
Heineken
Stella Artois
Corona
Guinness (Can Only)
Specialty Drinks
Strawberry Sangria
Smirnoff Strawberry Vodka, Strawberry-Cran juice and Sauvignon Blanc
Peachtini
Smirnoff Peach Vodka, peach puree and homemade sour mix
Lavender Collins
Bombay Sapphire Gin and homemade lavender syrup, topped with club soda and garnished with a lemon twist
Blueberry Margarita
Sauza Silver Tequila, homemade blueberry puree, fresh lime juice and orange bitters served with a salted rim
Island Cocktail
Smirnoff Pineapple Vodka, Malibu Coconut Rum, pineapple juice, cranberry juice and homemade cherry syrup
Hickory House Signature Drinks
Scarlet & Gray
Smirnoff Citrus Vodka, Blue Caraco, sour mix and cranberry juice, with a raspberry float
Steak House Martini
Buckeye Vodka and bleu cheese olives served on the rocks or up
Hickory House Bloody Mary
Smirnoff Citrus Vodka and homemade bloody Mary mix served with a rib-spiced rim, celery stick, lime wedge & olive
New Fashion
Smirnoff Orange Vodka, Pomegranate Liquor, sour mix and muddled oranges
Hickory House Sour
Jim Beam, homemade sour mix, shaken and topped with a red wine float
Classic Side Car
Brandy and Triple Sec served with a sugar rim on the rocks or up
Hickory’s “New” Old Fashions
Classic
Watershed Bourbon, bitters, sugar, cherry and orange
Cherry
Southern Comfort, bitters, sugar, cherry, orange and homemade cherry syrup
Orange
Jim Beam, orange bitters, sugar, oranges and Orange Crush soda
Elderflower
Maker’s Mark, Elderflower Liquor, bitters, sugar, cherry and orange
Sodas & More
Coke
Diet Coke
Mr. Pibb
Sprite
Mellow Yellow
Coke Zero
Cherry Coke
Ginger Ale
Lemonade
Tonic
Fruit Punch
Tea
iced and hot
Homemade Sweet Tea
Coffee
regular and decaf
2% Milk
Sunday
Homemade Bloody Mary $5.00
Retail Wine Night
3:00 pm to close
Monday – Smirnoff Martinis
Passion Fruit
Smirnoff Vodka, passion fruit puree and orange juice
Pear Cosmo
Smirnoff Pear Vodka, Triple Sec, fresh lime juice and cranberry juice
Lemon Drop
Smirnoff Citrus Vodka, fresh lemon juice and sour mix, served with a sugar rim
Key Lime
Smirnoff Vanilla Vodka, Triple Sec and fresh lime juice
Pineapple Upside Down Cake
Smirnoff Pineapple Vodka, Smirnoff Vanilla Vodka and pineapple juice
Tuesday
Fresh Squeezed Margaritas
including Peach & Strawberry
$5.00
Wednesday
All Canyon Road House Wine $5.00
Thursday
Long Island Ice Tea $5.00
Friday & Saturday
Bartender’s Choice $5.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Contact Hickory House Restaurant

Address: 7051 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068

Phone: (614) 861-5962

Website: https://thehickoryhouse.com/reynoldsburg-steakhouse/

Hours

Saturday 12–10PM
Sunday 12–9PM
Monday 12–9PM
Tuesday 12–9PM
Wednesday 12–9PM
Thursday 12–9PM
Friday 12–10PM

Related Web Results

Hickory House – Steakhouse

Thank you central Ohio for your continued support. We’re looking forward to another 39 years of serving you! Reynoldsburg Hickory House Steakhouse …

Reynoldsburg – Hickory House

Located at 7051 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068. The Hickory house is central Ohio’s steakhouse serving Reynoldsburg and Gahanna. We believe in tradition and …

Dinner Menu – Gahanna – Hickory House

of Bar-B-Que sauce. 14.95. The Pub Sub. Roast beef topped with American and cheddar cheese and onion straws on a hoagie roll.

Leave a Comment