Original Frozen Custard Menu Prices

by

Enduring shop, founded in 1932, selling frozen custard, burgers, old-fashioned sodas & shakes.

Original Frozen Custard serves the Lafayette, Indiana community with delicious frozen custard. Our secret recipe has been passed down from generation to generation since 1932. Our homemade frozen custard has been a staple in the community for years, bringing people to our frozen custard shop for the best frozen treats. We serve various flavors of frozen custard, fresh fruit drink, sandwiches, old fashioned sodas, ice cream sundaes, shakes, malts and other desserts. Visit our frozen custard shop located across from the Columbian Park Zoo and taste why our frozen custard is the best in town.

  4.2 – 392 reviews  $$ • Ice cream shop

Photo Gallery

Menu

Our Specials
Sandwiches
Bacon Mushroom Swiss Burger
Coney Dogs & Coney Cheese Dog
Coney sauce made fresh in house
Frozen Treats
Mint Bars
Mint Frozen Custard dipped in chocolate and rolled in Oreo’s
Chocolate Covered Cheese Cake on a Stick
Specialty Sundaes
Our Treats
Dirt Sundae
Vanilla Frozen Custard with crushed Oreo topping and a gummi worm		 $5.49
Banana Split
Vanilla Frozen Custard on sliced bananas with chocolate syrup, strawberries, pineapple, pecans and whipped cream		 $9.99
Turtle
Vanilla Frozen Custard with hot fudge, warm butterscotch, pecans and whipped cream		 $6.95
Fudge Muffin Sundae
Vanilla Frozen Custard on a double chocolate chip muffin topped with hot fudge and whipped cream		 $6.99
Black and Gold
Vanilla Frozen Custard with hot fudge, peanut butter, pea nuts and whipped cream. Black and White: Vanilla Frozen Custard with hot fudge, marshmallow, peanuts and whipped cream		 $6.95
Pound Cake Sundae
Vanilla Frozen Custard on a Sara Lee Pound Cake with your choice of topping		 $6.99
Rocky Road
Chocolate Frozen Custard with marshmallow topping, peanuts and whipped cream		 $6.95
Mint Mountain
Vanilla Frozen Custard covered with chocolate sauce, Mint Chips and whipped cream		 $6.95
Soggy Bottom
Vanilla Frozen Custard on top of crushed OREO, Covered with Peanut Butter and Marshmallow		 $6.95
Create Your Own Sundae
Vanilla Frozen Custard with your choice of topping: chocolate, strawberry, hot fudge, warm butterscotch, pineapple, boysenberry, tigers blood, marshmallow, lemon, cherry or lime		 $5.19
Sundae with nuts
$1.25 extra. Georgia Pecans and Spanish Peanuts
Sandwiches
Sandwiches
Double Cheese Burger $5.99
Double Hamburger $4.99
Breaded Tenderloin $5.99
Breaded Chicken Breast $5.99
Corn Dog $2.89
Grilled Tenderloin $5.99
Cheese Burger
¼ lb. Black Angus		 $4.19
Hamburger
¼ lb. Black Angus		 $3.99
Chicken Salad Croissant $4.29
Grilled Chicken Breast $5.99
Breaded Cod
Condiments: Ketchup, mayo, onions, lettuce, dill pickles, sweet relish & mustard. Tomato, Nacho Cheese, Chili, Bacon available as an extra cost		 $5.99
Popcorn Chicken $4.94
Coney Cheese Dog $3.09
Cheese Dog $2.79
Popcorn Chicken and Wedges $5.59
Coney Dog $2.79
Hot Dog $1.80
Pasta Salad
Rotini Pasta & Monterey Jack, with either: popcorn chicken, grilled Chicken, or chicken salad		 $6.47
Frozen Custard Flavors
Frozen Custard Flavors
Cake Cones & Dishes $5.75
Waffle Cones $6.50
Munchies
Munchies
Breaded Pickles $3.59
Corn Nuggets $3.59
Mushrooms $3.59
Bosco Cheese Stuffed Breadsticks $3.29
Chili Cheese Fries $3.59
Cheese Fries $3.10
Onion Rings $3.59
Potato Wedges & Cheese $3.59
Potato Wedges $2.69
French Fries $1.87
Nachos & Cheese $3.29
Pretzel Sticks $2.99
Lafayette’s Finest Burgers
Lafayette’s Finest Burgers
Bacon Burger
Ground Chuck topped with thick Cut Bacon and Provolone		 $6.99
Texas Burger
Ground Chuck topped with barbeque sauce, diced raw onions, Onion Rings and Smothered with Provolone Cheese		 $6.99
Wisconsin Cheese Burger
6 ounces of Ground Chuck Smothered with Colby Jack Cheese		 $6.99
Spicy Jalapeño Burger
Ground Chuck topped with jalapeño slices and Pepper Jack Cheese		 $6.99
Fountain Drinks
Fountain Drinks
Old Fashion Soda
Vanilla Frozen Custard and Fizzed with soda water: chocolate, strawberry, vanilla, lemon, lime, boysenberry, pineapple, cherry or tiger’s blood		 $3.99
Floats
Vanilla Frozen Custard with Coke, Root Beer, Sprite, or any of the Diet Cokes		 $3.99
Shakes
Vanilla, chocolate, strawberry pineapple, butterscotch, marshmallow, cherry, boysenberry, lime, lemon, tiger’s blood, blue moon, or hot fudge		 $4.00
Malts
Shake with malted milk, same flavors as shakes.		 $4.47
Chunky Shake
Vanilla shake with Snicker’s, M&M’s, Butterfinger’s, Reeces Pieces, Reeces Cup, Nestle Crunch, or OREO		 $5.01
Slush
Cherry, blue raspberry, strawberry, grape, watermelon, orange, lemon lime, and pomegranate		 $3.75
Brain Freeze
½ Shake ½ Slush, same flavors as slush		 $3.99
Coke Cooler, Sprite Spritzer, Popo’s Punch
½ slush		 $2.83
Fruit Drink
A secret blend of citrus juices		 $4.99
Phosphates
Ice, soda water, and flavor: vanilla, cherry, lime, lemon, boysenberry, and/or tiger’s blood		 $2.34
Triple Filtered Lafayette Pearl River Water
In foam cup with ice, lid and straw.		 $1.31
Bag of Frozen Custard Ice
Just a bag, filled, not weighed		 $3.29
Drinks
Coke
Diet Coke
Coke Zero
Barq’s Root Beer
Sprite
Caffeine-Free Diet Coke
Peak Tea Unsweetened
Flavored with: vanilla, cherry, chocolate, lemon, boysenberry, lime, marshmallow, and/or tiger’s blood
Peak Sweet Tea
Flavored with: vanilla, cherry, chocolate, lemon, boysenberry, lime, marshmallow, and/or tiger’s blood

… View more

Menu Photos

Contact Original Frozen Custard

Address: 2319 Wallace Ave, Lafayette, IN 47904

Phone: (765) 447-2492

Website: https://www.originalfrozencustard.com/

Hours

Friday 11AM–8PM
Saturday 11AM–8PM
Sunday 12–7PM
Monday 11AM–7PM
Tuesday 11AM–7PM
Wednesday 11AM–7PM
Thursday 11AM–7PM

Related Web Results

Original Frozen Custard – Frozen Custard Treats | Lafayette …

Original Frozen Custard is not your average ice cream store! We make homemade frozen custard for Lafayette, IN. Try a wide variety of flavors!

Our Menu | Lafayette, Indiana – Original Frozen Custard

Specialty Sundaes ; Turtle Vanilla Frozen Custard with hot fudge, warm butterscotch, pecans and whipped cream. ; Fudge Muffin Sundae Vanilla Frozen Custard on a …

Our Histroy | Lafayette, Indiana – Original Frozen Custard

In 1932, Florence and Charles Kirkhoff opened … The Original Frozen Custard. Little is known about what inspired them to open up their very own frozen custard …

Leave a Comment