Papa Ray’s Pizza & Wings Menu Prices at 1267 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203

Small, counter-serve spot serving thin-crust pizzas, wings & rib tips in a no-frills space.

Papa Ray’s Pizza & Wings remains one of the most popular in Indianapolis. Give them a try and see what makes them such a favorite. For a true flavor of the city, try some of Indianapolis’s top dishes. See what all the fuss is about with these local favorites. Try Cheese BYO Calzone for a truly local taste. One taste and you’ll get why it’s such a favorite. Don’t miss out on Fries while ordering your pizza!

3.6 – 670 reviews $ • Pizza restaurant

Photo Gallery

Papa Ray’s Pizza & Wings menu
All Day – Specialty Pizzas
The Works Pizza Small 10″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, Italian sausage, pepperoni, fresh onions, black olives, mushrooms and green peppers.	$13.99
The Works Pizza Medium 12″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, Italian sausage, pepperoni, fresh onions, black olives, mushrooms and green peppers.	$17.99
The Works Pizza Large 14″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, Italian sausage, pepperoni, fresh onions, black olives, mushrooms and green peppers.	$22.99
The Works Pizza Extra Large 16″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, Italian sausage, pepperoni, fresh onions, black olives, mushrooms and green peppers.	$25.99
Italian Sausage Pizza Small 10″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, sausage, onions, fresh mushrooms and green peppers.	$13.99
Italian Sausage Pizza Medium 12″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, sausage, onions, fresh mushrooms and green peppers.	$17.99
Italian Sausage Pizza Large 14″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, sausage, onions, fresh mushrooms and green peppers.	$21.99
Italian Sausage Pizza Extra Large 16″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, sausage, onions, fresh mushrooms and green peppers.	$24.99
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Small 10″ Papa Ray’s hot sauce, chunks of fresh chicken and Bermuda onions.	$13.99
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Medium 12″ Papa Ray’s hot sauce, chunks of fresh chicken and Bermuda onions.	$17.99
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Large 14″ Papa Ray’s hot sauce, chunks of fresh chicken and Bermuda onions.	$21.99
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Extra Large 16″ Papa Ray’s hot sauce, chunks of fresh chicken and Bermuda onions.	$24.99
Meat- Atarian Pizza Small 10″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, Italian sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon and ground beef.	$13.99
Meat- Atarian Pizza Medium 12″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, Italian sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon and ground beef.	$17.99
Meat- Atarian Pizza Large 14″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, Italian sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon and ground beef.	$21.99
Meat- Atarian Pizza Extra Large 16″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, Italian sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon and ground beef.	$24.99
Vegetarian Pizza Small 10″ Vegetarian. Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, fresh onions, fresh mushrooms, green peppers and fresh spinach.	$13.99
Vegetarian Pizza Medium 12″ Vegetarian. Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, fresh onions, fresh mushrooms, green peppers and fresh spinach.	$17.99
Vegetarian Pizza Large 14″ Vegetarian. Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, fresh onions, fresh mushrooms, green peppers and fresh spinach.	$20.99
Vegetarian Pizza Extra Large 16″ Vegetarian. Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, fresh onions, fresh mushrooms, green peppers and fresh spinach.	$23.99
Tropical Hawaiian Pizza Small 10″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, Canadian bacon, crispy smoked bacon and sweet pineapple.	$13.99
Tropical Hawaiian Pizza Medium 12″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, Canadian bacon, crispy smoked bacon and sweet pineapple.	$17.99
Tropical Hawaiian Pizza Large 14″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, Canadian bacon, crispy smoked bacon and sweet pineapple.	$21.99
Tropical Hawaiian Pizza Extra Large 16″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, Canadian bacon, crispy smoked bacon and sweet pineapple.	$24.99
Classic Sausage And Pepperoni Pizza Small 10″ Double sausage and double pepperoni.	$13.99
Classic Sausage And Pepperoni Pizza Medium 12″ Double sausage and double pepperoni.	$17.99
Classic Sausage And Pepperoni Pizza Large 14″ Double sausage and double pepperoni.	$21.99
Classic Sausage And Pepperoni Pizza Extra Large 16″ Double sausage and double pepperoni.	$24.99
Chicken Club Pizza Small 10″ Chicken breast, bacon, fresh tomatoes and Bermuda onions.	$13.99
Chicken Club Pizza Medium 12″ Chicken breast, bacon, fresh tomatoes and Bermuda onions.	$17.99
Chicken Club Pizza Large 14″ Chicken breast, bacon, fresh tomatoes and Bermuda onions.	$21.99
Chicken Club Pizza Extra Large 16″ Chicken breast, bacon, fresh tomatoes and Bermuda onions.	$24.99
BBQ Chicken Pizza Small 10″ BBQ sauce, cilantro, Bermuda onions and chunks of fresh chicken.	$13.99
BBQ Chicken Pizza Medium 12″ BBQ sauce, cilantro, Bermuda onions and chunks of fresh chicken.	$17.99
BBQ Chicken Pizza Large 14″ BBQ sauce, cilantro, Bermuda onions and chunks of fresh chicken.	$21.99
BBQ Chicken Pizza Extra Large 16″ BBQ sauce, cilantro, Bermuda onions and chunks of fresh chicken.	$24.99
Florentine Pizza Small 10″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, fresh tomatoes, fresh spinach, fresh garlic and topped with basil.	$13.99
Florentine Pizza Medium 12″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, fresh tomatoes, fresh spinach, fresh garlic and topped with basil.	$17.99
Florentine Pizza Large 14″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, fresh tomatoes, fresh spinach, fresh garlic and topped with basil.	$21.99
Florentine Pizza Extra Large 16″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, fresh tomatoes, fresh spinach, fresh garlic and topped with basil.	$24.99
Greek Pizza Small 10″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, feta cheese, fresh tomatoes, fresh basil, fresh garlic and black olives.	$13.99
Greek Pizza Medium 12″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, feta cheese, fresh tomatoes, fresh basil, fresh garlic and black olives.	$17.99
Greek Pizza Large 14″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, feta cheese, fresh tomatoes, fresh basil, fresh garlic and black olives.	$21.99
Greek Pizza Extra Large 16″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, feta cheese, fresh tomatoes, fresh basil, fresh garlic and black olives.	$24.99
Mediterranean Style Pizza Small 10″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, artichokes, fresh onions, fresh tomatoes and freshly chopped garlic.	$13.99
Mediterranean Style Pizza Medium 12″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, artichokes, fresh onions, fresh tomatoes and freshly chopped garlic.	$17.99
Mediterranean Style Pizza Large 14″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, artichokes, fresh onions, fresh tomatoes and freshly chopped garlic.	$21.99
Mediterranean Style Pizza Extra Large 16″ Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, artichokes, fresh onions, fresh tomatoes and freshly chopped garlic.	$24.99
Papas Choice Pizza Small 10″ Choice of any four ingredients.	$13.99
Papas Choice Pizza Medium 12″ Choice of any four ingredients.	$17.99
Papas Choice Pizza Large 14″ Choice of any four ingredients.	$21.99
Papas Choice Pizza Extra Large 16″ Choice of any four ingredients.	$24.99
All Day – Pizza
Cheese Pizza Small 10″	$11.49
Cheese Pizza Medium 12″	$13.99
Cheese Pizza Large 14″	$15.99
Cheese Pizza Extra Large 16″	$17.99
All Day – Starters
Cheesy Garlic Bread Freshly made bread topped with our special garlic and parmesan sauce and topped with a generous amount of mozzarella cheese toasted and served with marinara sauce.	$6.49
Parmesan Garlic Bread Freshly baked bread topped with our special garlic butter sauce, parmesan and Italian seasonings.	$5.99
Ray’s Fries	$4.49
Ray’s Cheesy Fries	$5.49
Bacon Cheese Fries	$5.99
All Day – Traditional Wings
75 Pieces Traditional Wings Choice of three wing sauces and seven dipping sauces.	$82.99
100 Pieces Traditional Wings Choice of five wing sauces and ten dipping sauces.	$102.99
All Day – Boneless Wings
50 Pieces Boneless Wings Choose three flavors and five dipping sauces.	$54.99
100 Pieces Boneless Wings Choose five flavors and ten dipping sauces.	$100.99
All Day – Salads
Papa Ray’s House Salad Romaine lettuce with artichoke hearts, green peppers, kalamata olives, tomatoes, onions and feta cheese. Served with your choice of dressing.	$8.99
Chicken Caesar Salad Romaine lettuce, fresh parmesan and Asiago cheese, croutons, fresh tomatoes topped with marinated grilled chicken. Served with your choice of dressing.	$8.99
Garden Salad Romaine lettuce, fresh tomatoes, Bermuda onions, mushrooms and green peppers. Served with your choice of dressing.	$7.99
Caesar Salad Romaine lettuce, fresh parmesan and Asiago cheese, croutons and fresh tomatoes. Served with your choice of dressing.	$7.99
Four Seasons Salad Romaine lettuce, red onions, Canadian ham, macaroni noodles, fresh tomatoes and topped with Asiago cheese. Served with your choice of dressing.	$8.49
Chopped Salad Romaine lettuce, mozzarella cheese, bacon and grilled chicken.	$8.99
All Day – Calzone Wraps
Calzone Wrap Delicious calzone wraps wrapped in out butter crust with Papa Ray’s cheese blend and home-made tomato sauce.	$8.49
Italian Sausage Calzone Wrap Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, Italian sausage, onions, fresh mushrooms and green peppers.	$9.49
The Works Calzone Wrap Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, Italian sausage, pepperoni, onions, black olives, fresh mushrooms and green peppers.	$9.49
Chicken Club Calzone Wrap Chicken breast, bacon, fresh tomatoes and Bermuda onions.	$9.49
Florentine Calzone Wrap Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, fresh tomatoes, fresh spinach, fresh garlic and basil.	$9.49
Vegetarian Calzone Wrap Vegetarian. Papa Ray’s pizza sauce, onions, fresh mushrooms, green peppers and fresh spinach.	$9.49
All Day – Build Your Own Mac & Cheese
Build Your Own Mac & Cheese (Small)	$7.99
Build Your Own Mac & Cheese (Large) A tasty blend of mozzarella and cheddar cheeses.	$9.99
All Day – Beverages
Can Soda	$1.49
6-Pack Soda Most popular.	$5.99
2-Liters	$4.49