New Sheffield Cafe Menu Prices

  4.3 – 495 reviews  $ • American restaurant

Photo Gallery

Menu

Lunch/Dinner
Starters
*NEW* Loaded Pierogies
Try out our new Loaded Pierogies! Choose from Potato, Loaded Potato, Spinach Artichoke, Jalapeno Popper, and Buffalo Chicken. You get 5 for $7.95!
$8.25
Hot Cheese Balls
Deep fried hot pepper cheese served with horsey sauce.
$8.25
Fried Banana Pepper Rings
Served with horsey sauce.
$9.25
Provolone Sticks
Served with marinara sauce.
$7.25
Zucchini Planks
Topped with parmesan cheese and served with marinara sauce.
$9.25
Fried Mushrooms $8.25
Fried Pickles $8.25
Fried Shrimp App $9.45
Coconut Shrimp App
6 crispy coconut battered shrimp served with our pina colada sauce
$9.45
Potato Skins
Loaded with cheddar cheese and bacon crumbles. Served with sour cream.
$9.25
Munchie Platter
Potato skins, fried zucchini, provolone sticks, hot pepper cheese balls, and beer battered onion rings. Enough for sharing!
$15.25
Nachos w/Cheese
Our house made tortilla chips topped with cheese sauce and jalapeno peppers. Served with sour cream.
$8.45
Nachos Supreme w/Chicken
Crispy nachos loaded with chicken. Topped with cheese, tomatoes, black olives, and jalapenos. Served with salsa and sour cream.
$15.25
Nachos Supreme w/Beef
Crispy nachos loaded with spicy beef. Topped with cheese, tomatoes, black olives, and jalapenos. Served with salsa and sour cream.
$15.25
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
Fresh spinach and artichokes in a bubbly cheese sauce topped with melted provolone and diced tomatoes. Served with our house made tortilla chips and bite sized Italian bread bites.
$11.25
Buffalo Chicken Dip
Served with our house made tortilla chips.
$11.25
Stuffed Hot Banana Peppers
3 banana peppers stuffed with a mixture of hot sausage and cheese. Topped with marinara sauce, and mozzarella cheese. Served with a breadstick.
$11.25
Steak Quesadilla
Made with shredded cheddar, provolone, and grilled peppers and onions.
$12.45
Chicken Quesadilla
Made with shredded cheddar, provolone, and grilled peppers and onions.
$11.45
Shrimp Quesadilla
Made with shredded cheddar, provolone, and grilled peppers and onions.
$13.45
Basket of Breadsticks
Garlic breadsticks dusted with parmesan cheese. Served with marinara.
$6.45
Bavarian Pretzel Sticks
6 Bavarian pretzel sticks served with your choice of cheddar cheese sauce or beer cheese dip.
$9.25
Basket of Quip Chips $7.25
Basket of Fries $6.25
Basket of Onion Rings $7.45
Basket of Sweet Potato Fries $7.25
Basket of Waffle Fries $7.25
Sides
Side of Fries $3.45
Side of Quip Chips $3.45
Side of Onion Rings $3.45
Side of Fried Banana Pepper Rings $3.45
Side of Waffle Fries $3.45
Side of Sweet Potato Fries $3.45
Side of Mac & Cheese $3.25
Bowl of Mac & Cheese $4.25
Side of Cole Slaw $1.80
Side of Mashed Potatoes $3.25
Soup
Chili – Take Out Bowl
Meaty and delicious with just the right amount of spices!
$4.75
Salads
Steak Salad
Our house specialty! We start with a bed of fresh lettuce surrounded with hard boiled egg slices, onions, tomato, black olives, and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries, provolone cheese, and our delicious sirloin.
Chicken Salad
Grilled chicken filet served atop fresh lettuce with hard boiled egg slices, onions, tomatoes, black olives, and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries, and provolone cheese.
Nugget Salad
Tasty fried chicken tenders on a bed of lettuce, provolone cheese, onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini, and golden fries.
Chicken & Steak Salad
Fish Salad
Our lightly breaded cod deep-fried to a golden brown atop a crisp bed of lettuce with hard boiled egg slices, tomatoes, onions, black olives, and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries and provolone cheese.
Gyro Salad
We start with a bed of fresh lettuce, surrounded with hard boiled egg slices, onions, tomatoes, black olives, and pepperoncini. Topped with golden fries, and crumbled feta cheese. Served with our house made dill sauce and a pita.
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce topped with croutons, shaved parmesan, and Caesar dressing.
Chef Salad
Fresh lettuce topped with delicious ham, salami, and lean turkey. Garnished with hard boiled egg slices, tomatoes, onions, black olives, pepperoncini, and provolone cheese.
Grilled Shrimp Salad
Our fresh grilled shrimp atop a bed of lettuce with hard boiled egg slices, onions, black olives, and pepperoncini. Topped off with golden fries and provolone cheese.
Taco Salad
A crisp bed of lettuce topped with onions, tomatoes, black olives, pepperoncini, and cheddar cheese. Topped with our house made tortilla chips, chili, and melted cheddar cheese sauce. A Mexican treat! Served with salsa and sour cream.
Tossed Salad
Crisp lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, black olives, and pepperoncini. Served with your choice of dressing.
Wings
Whole Wings
Wingers (12)
12 jumbo cut wings
$17.25
Boneless Wings
Plump, juicy all white meat. They’re great! No bones about it!
Sandwiches
Hot Roast Beef Sandwich
Lean and thick slices of beef piled high on Italian bread. Served with your choice of mashed potatoes or fries and gravy.
$13.45
Hot Turkey Sandwich
Lean and thick slices of our fresh baked turkey breast piled high on Italian bread. Served with your choice of mashed potatoes or fries and gravy.
$12.45
Hot Hamburger
Our fresh grilled burger on Italian bread. Served with your choice of mashed potatoes or fries and gravy.
$11.45
Gyro
Savory gyro meat, lettuce, tomato, onion, and our fresh made cucumber dill sauce served on pita bread.
$8.75
Italian Hoagie
Generous portions of ham, salami, pepperoni, and provolone cheese. Toasted and topped with lettuce, tomato, and onion. Served with Italian dressing on the side.
$10.45
Philly Steak Hoagie
Thinly sliced sirloin grilled with sauteed mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Topped with provolone cheese on a fresh grilled hoagie bun.
$10.15
Chicken Philly Hoagie
Thinly sliced chicken breast grilled with sauteed mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. Topped with provolone cheese on a grilled hoagie bun.
$9.65
Meatball Hoagie
Lori’s delicious meatballs topped with our tangy sauce, and melted provolone cheese.
$9.45
Hot Sausage Sandwich
Hot sausage patty smothered in peppers and onions and topped with provolone cheese. Served on a fresh grilled hoagie bun with a side of sauce.
$8.45
Reuben Sandwich
Our tasty corned beef topped with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and dressing. Served on grilled rye bread.
$11.15
Triple Decker
Turkey, baked ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise stacked high between three slices of toasted sourdough bread.
$10.15
Turkey Bacon Club
Turkey, bacon, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise stacked high between three slices of sourdough bread.
$11.15
Fish Sandwich
Generous haddock fillet, hand breaded and deep fried golden brown.
$12.75
Tuna Melt
Our tuna salad topped with American cheese and grilled to perfection on sourdough bread.
$8.45
Grilled Cheese
Your choice of American, provolone, Swiss, cheddar, or pepper jack cheese. Grilled on your choice of rye or sourdough bread.
$6.45
BLT
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on toasted sourdough bread.
$8.15
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Tender chicken fillet lightly seasoned and grilled to perfection. Topped with lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.
$8.15
Build-A-Burger
Make your own creation. Includes your choice of cheese and up to four toppings.
$10.45
Baskets & Wraps
Chicken Tenders & Fries Basket
Hand breaded fresh white meat chicken deep fried crispy along side fries. Try them buffalo style or with any of our other wing sauces.
$10.45
Fish Basket
Cod nuggets served with fries and cole slaw.
$12.15
Shrimp Basket
Butterfly shrimp served with fries and cole slaw.
$13.15
Coconut Shrimp Basket
Butterfly coconut shrimp served with fries, cole slaw, and our pina colada dipping sauce.
$14.15
Grilled Chicken Wrap
Grilled chicken in a warm tortilla wrap with lettuce, shredded provolone, ranch dressing, and our red pepper pesto. Served with fries.
$10.95
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Fried chicken tenders tossed in buffalo sauce in a warm tortilla wrap with lettuce, shredded provolone, ranch dressing, and our red pepper pesto. Served with fries.
$10.95
Burger Wrap
Our very own house made angus beef burger wrapped in a warm tortilla with lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, and your choice of cheese. Served with fries.
$10.95
Kiddie Menu
KIDS Cheeseburger Sliders (2) & Fries
Available for our guests 12 years old and younger. Drink included.
$5.95
KIDS Chicken Nuggets & Fries
Available for our guests 12 years old and younger. Drink included.
$5.45
KIDS Fish Nuggets & Fries
Available for our guests 12 years old and younger. Drink included.
$6.45
KIDS Grilled Cheese & Fries
Available for our guests 12 years old and younger. Drink included.
$4.95
KIDS Linguine & Meatball
Available for our guests 12 years old and younger. Drink included.
$5.45
Cafe Favorites
Steak N’ Noodles
Generous portion of noodles served with our fresh grilled sirloin tips, fresh sliced mushrooms, and smothered in our house made gravy. Served with a tossed salad and breadstick.
$14.95
Bret’s Special
A mix of fresh grilled steak, chicken breast, and grilled shrimp. Served with our rice pilaf, fresh green beans, tossed salad, and breadstick.
$16.25
Chicken Naturelle
Two tender grilled chicken fillets, lightly seasoned. Served with fresh green beans, BBQ sauce for dipping, tossed salad, and breadstick.
$14.45
Cafe Kabobs
Lamb Kabob
Lamb grilled to perfection on a skewer. Served with a tossed salad, rice pilaf, and a pita.
$14.95
Beef Kabob
Beef grilled to perfection on a skewer. Served with a tossed salad, rice pilaf, and a pita.
$14.45
Lamb & Beef Kabob
Lamb and beef grilled to perfection on a skewer. Served with a tossed salad, rice pilaf, and a pita.
$14.95
Chicken Kabob
Grilled chicken grilled to perfection on a skewer. Served with a tossed salad, rice pilaf, and a pita.
$13.45
Shrimp Kabob
Shrimp grilled to perfection on a skewer. Served with a tossed salad, rice pilaf, and a pita.
$14.95
Cafe Mixes
Steak Mixer
A mix of steak, golden fries, shredded provolone and cheddar cheese, and your choice of dressing. Sure to be a favorite!
$14.45
Chicken Mixer
A mix of grilled chicken, golden fries, shredded provolone and cheddar cheese, and your choice of dressing. Sure to be a favorite!
$13.25
Nugget Mixer
A mix of fried chicken tenders, golden fries, shredded provolone and cheddar cheese, and your choice of dressing. Sure to be a favorite!
$11.25
Steak & Chicken Mixer
A mix of steak and grilled chicken, golden fries, shredded provolone and cheddar cheese, and your choice of dressing. Sure to be a favorite!
$14.45
Steak & Nugget Mixer
A mix of steak and fried chicken tenders, golden fries, shredded provolone and cheddar cheese, and your choice of dressing. Sure to be a favorite!
$12.45
Gyro Mixer
A mix of sliced gyro meat, golden fries, shredded provolone and cheddar cheese, and your choice of dressing. Sure to be a favorite!
$10.45
Pasta
Fettuccine Alfredo
Served with a tossed salad and breadstick.
$11.45
Linguine & Meatball
Served with a tossed salad and breadstick.
$10.45
Penne Ala Vodka
Served with a tossed salad and breadstick.
$11.45
Desserts
Bananas Foster Pie $8.45
Carrot Cake $8.45
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake $8.95
Colossal Chocolate Mousse Cake $8.45
German Chocolate Cake $7.45
Italian Lemon Creme Cake $7.45
Limoncello Cake $6.45
New York Colossal Cheesecake $8.45
Peanut Butter Pie $8.45
Salted Carmel Brownie w/Pretzel Crust $5.45
Snickers Pie $8.45
Summerberry Stack Cake $7.45
Triple Chocolate Cheesecake $8.45
Extras – Veggies
Side of Lettuce $1.39
Side of Egg $1.39
Side of Fried Egg $1.39
Side of Onion $1.39
Side of Olive $1.39
Side of Tomato $1.39
Side of Peppercini $1.39
Side of Mushrooms $1.39
Side of Grilled Mushrooms $1.39
Side of Grilled Onions $1.39
Side of Red Peppers $1.39
Side of Roasted Red Peppers $1.39
Side of Jalapenos $1.39
Side of Green Beans $1.99
Side of Avocado $1.99
Side of Celery $1.39
Side of Pickles $1.39
Extras – Meat
Side of Steak $5.49
Side of Chicken $5.49
Side of Chicken Nuggets $5.49
Side of Shrimp $6.49
Side of Gyro Meat $5.49
Side of Fish $5.49
Side of Bacon $2.49
Side of Meatballs $5.49
Side of Beef (Kabob) $5.49
Side of Lamb $5.49
Side of Burger Meat $5.49
Side of Roast Beef $5.49
Side of Turkey $5.49
Side of Corned Beef $5.49
Extras – Bread and Pasta
Breadstick $1.29
Side of Croutons $0.99
Side of Rice Pilaf $3.15
Side of Hush Puppies $3.15
Side of Tortilla Chips $3.15
Side of Bread Bites $2.95
Side of Pita $1.39
Extras – Cheese
Side of Cubed Cheese $1.39
Side of Shredded Cheese $1.39
Side of Cubed and Shredded Cheese $1.39
Side of Shredded Cheddar $1.39
Side of Shredded Mix $1.39
Side of Feta $1.99
Side of Shaved Parmesan $1.49
Side of Parmesan Cheese $1.39
Side of American Cheese $1.39
Side of Provolone Cheese $1.39
Side of Cheddar Cheese $1.39
Side of Pepper Jack Cheese $1.39
Side of Swiss Cheese $1.39
Side of Nacho Cheese $1.39
Side of Beer Cheese $1.39
Extras – Sauces and Dressings
Side of BBQ $1.39
Side of Honey BBQ $1.39
Side of Carolina Tangy BBQ $1.39
Side of Hot $1.39
Side of Honey Garlic Stinger $1.39
Side of Sweet Teriyaki $1.39
Side of Candy Pepper $1.39
Side of Butter Garlic $1.39
Side of Garlic Parmesan $1.39
Side of Buffalo Bleu $1.39
Side of Pineapple Habanero $1.39
Side of Seasoned $1.39
Side of Cajun $1.39
Side of Deli BBQ $1.39
Side of Ranch $1.39
Side of Sweet & Sour $1.39
Side of 1000 Island $1.39
Side of Bleu Cheese $1.39
Side of Italian $1.39
Side of French $1.39
Side of Balsamic $1.39
Side of Oil and Vinegar $1.39
Side of Honey Mustard $1.39
Side of Caesar $1.39
Side of Dill $1.39
Side of Mayo
Side of Ketchup
Side of Mustard
Side of Brown Gravy $1.39
Side of Turkey Gravy $1.39
Side of Yum Yum Sauce $1.39
Side of Horsey $1.39
Side of Cocktail $0.59
Side of Pina Colada $1.39
Side of Tartar $0.59
Side of Salsa $1.39
Side of Sour Cream $1.39
Side of Marinara Sauce $1.39
Side of Alfredo Sauce $1.39
Side of Vodka Sauce $1.39
Extras – Dip
Side of Spinach Artichoke Dip $4.49
Beverages
Pepsi
Can
$1.50
Diet Pepsi
Can
$1.50
Mountain Dew
Can
$1.50
Ginger Ale
Can
$1.50
Root Beer
Can
$1.50
Orange Crush
Can
$1.50
Sprite
Can
$1.50
Unsweetened Iced Tea
Can
$1.50
Raspberry Iced Tea
Can
$1.50
Water
Bottle
$1.00
Breakfast
Omelettes
Cheese $8.99
Western $11.19
Greek $11.19
Hot & Spicy $11.19
Meat Lovers $12.49
Philly Steak $13.49
Seafood $13.19
Build Your Own
With choice of ham, bacon, sausage or hot sausage, choice of one cheese and one veggie.
$11.49
Breakfast Combo
#1
2 Eggs and Toast
$6.15
#2
2 Eggs, choice of ham, bacon, sausage or hot sausage and toast.
$8.15
#3
2 Eggs, Home Fries or Hash Browns and Toast
$7.15
#4
2 Eggs, Home Fries or Hash Browns, Ham, Bacon, Sausage or Hot Sausage and Toast.
$9.15
#5
2 Eggs, Corned Beef Hash and Toast
$9.15
#6 Triple
Three eggs any style, choice of hash browns or home fries, choice of ham, bacon, sausage or hot sausage and toast.
$11.19
#7 Home Run
Three eggs any style, choice of hash browns or home fries, choice of ham, bacon, sausage or hot sausage and choice of one pancake or one piece of French toast
$13.19
#8 World Series
Three eggs any style, 8 oz steak, choice of hash browns or home fries and choice of one pancake or one piece of French toast
$15.99
From the Griddle
Pancakes
3 Pancakes with Ham, Bacon or Sausage
$9.95
French Toast
3 French Toast with Ham, Bacon or Sausage
$9.95
Belgian Waffle $8.49
Sandwiches & Wraps
Breakfast Sandwich $8.89
Breakfast Wrap $8.89
A La Carte
One Egg $1.59
English Muffin $1.99
Toast $1.99
Bagel Plain $1.89
Bagel with Cream Cheese $2.59
Croissant $1.99
Oatmeal $3.59
Grits $3.59
Pancake
1 Pancake
$2.99
Feta Cheese $1.59
Cream Cheese $0.79
Peanut Butter $0.99
Chocolate Chips $0.99
Blueberries $0.99
8oz Steak $12.20
Bacon $4.99
Ham $4.99
Sausage $4.99
Hot Sausage $4.99
Corned Beef Hash $4.99
1 Biscuit with Gravy $4.59
2 Biscuits with Gravy $7.79
Hash Browns $3.59
Home Fries $3.59
Kids Menu
#1 Egg
1 Egg, choice of Ham, Bacon or Sausage and Toast
$6.15
#2 French Toast
1 Piece of French Toast and choice of Ham, Bacon or Sausage
$6.15
#3 Pancake
1 Pancake and choice of Ham, Bacon or Sausage
$6.15
#4 Waffle
Half Belgian Waffle and choice of Ham, Bacon or Sausage
$6.15
Drinks
Coffee $2.55
Tea $2.55
Soda
Milk
Bruntons
$2.95
Hot Chocolate $2.35
Chocolate Milk
Bruntons
$2.95
Orange Juice $2.55
Apple Juice $2.55
Our Specials
Monday Specials
Whole Wings
On Monday’s we offer Whole Wings on special for $1.75 each
Tuesday Specials
Mixer Tuesday!
All Cafe Mixes are $1.00 off!
Wednesday Specials
Trio Kabob
Steak, Chicken, and Lamb – $13.95Includes Rice Pilaf, Pita Bread, Tossed Salad, and Breadstick!
Thursday Specials
Prime Rib Sandwich
Sandwich comes with Waffle Fries – $13.95
Friday Specials
Fish Special
Fish Sandwich w/Mac & Cheese – $14.95Includes Cole Slaw and Hush Puppies!
Saturday Specials
Large Salads Special!
Choose two large salads for the following prices:* 2 Chicken, Nugget, or 1 of each = $24.00* 1 Chicken/Nugget & 1 Steak = $24.00* 2 Steak = $26.00
Sunday Specials
Boneless Wings and Fries
1 LB of Boneless Wings and Fries – $13.95
Pizza
Pizza
8 Pizza
Meat Toppings – $1.79 EachVeggie Toppings – $1.59 EachExtra Cheese – $1.79SaucesRedButter GarlicAlfredoRanchRoasted Red Pepper PestoBasil PestoCheesesMozzarellaCheddarCheddar JackFetaFresh Mozzarella SlicesMeat ToppingsPepperoniSausageHot SausageHamBaconGyroGrilled ChickenPhilly ChickenChicken TendersVeggie ToppingsRed OnionMushroomsRed PeppersRoasted Red PeppersBanana PeppersJalapenosSpinachTomatoesBlack OlivesPineapple
$8.99
14 Pizza
Meat Toppings – $1.99 EachVeggie Toppings – $1.59 EachExtra Cheese – $1.79SaucesRedButter GarlicAlfredoRanchRoasted Red Pepper PestoBasil PestoCheesesMozzarellaCheddarCheddar JackFetaFresh Mozzarella SlicesMeat ToppingsPepperoniSausageHot SausageHamBaconGyroGrilled ChickenPhilly ChickenChicken TendersVeggie ToppingsRed OnionMushroomsRed PeppersRoasted Red PeppersBanana PeppersJalapenosSpinachTomatoesBlack OlivesPineapple
$12.99
Rolls
Pepperoni Rolls $6.99
Buffalo Chicken Rolls $7.99

… View more

Menu Photos

Contact New Sheffield Cafe

Address: 3154 Brodhead Rd, Aliquippa, PA 15001

Phone: (724) 375-5680

Website: https://www.newsheffield.cafe/

Hours

Saturday 8AM–10PM
Sunday 8AM–9PM
Monday 11AM–9PM
Tuesday 11AM–9PM
Wednesday 11AM–9PM
Thursday 11AM–9PM
Friday 8AM–10PM

Related Web Results

New Sheffield Cafe

New Sheffield Cafe in Aliquippa, PA. Call us at (724) 375-5680. Check out our location and hours, and latest menu with photos and reviews.

Menu – New Sheffield Cafe

Menu for New Sheffield Cafe in Aliquippa, PA. Explore latest menu with photos and reviews.

Order Online – New Sheffield Cafe

Explore our history, photos, and latest menu with reviews and ratings. … Tasty fried chicken tenders on a bed of lettuce, provolone cheese, onions, …

Leave a Comment